INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

Scottish Government guilty of contempt of court over FOI handling

10th June 2026

Scottish Government guilty of contempt of court over FOI handling.

Court of Session delivers notable precedent.

 

What has happened?

The Scottish Court of Session has found the Scottish Government (SG) guilty of contempt of court for failing to comply with a decision notice on time.

The case arose from a request relating to James Hamilton’s investigation into complaints about former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon. The Scottish Information Commissioner ordered disclosure of some of the withheld information but Scottish Ministers failed to comply within the deadline or seek an extension. They told the Commissioner that they could not comply just five minutes before the deadline expired. They eventually disclosed the information some six weeks late after contempt proceedings under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act (FOISA) had begun.

The SG told the court that it had to remove sensitive data from a large volume of documents and that the deadline included the Christmas period. But the court noted that the Commissioner’s notice was served on 1 December 2025 and although it required compliance by 15 January the SG did not begin to work on it “in earnest” until early January. The court rejected the SG’s view that the contempt proceedings were “irrational” stressing that the SG had knowingly failed to comply, that the deadline was a matter for the Commissioner not the authority and that the SG had had ample opportunity to appeal against the notice or apply for an extension.

There was “little contrition on the part of the Scottish Ministers” it noted. They had not admitted contempt, apologised or suggested they were taking measures to prevent a recurrence. “The tenor of the affidavit produced and submissions tended more towards indignation that the Commissioner had exercised his statutory powers in respect of the Scottish Ministers” it said.

The court found the SG guilty of contempt. Had it not done so it said “it might be seen as condoning the breach by a public authority of a deadline fixed by the Commissioner exercising statutory functions in compliance with the requirements of FOISA. That would send out the wrong signal to others tempted to do the same, diminish respect for decisions of the Commissioner, undermine the authority of the Commissioner, and subvert the rule of law.” It required the Scottish Government to pay the Commissioner’s costs.

Scroll to Top