28th May 2026
“Inexcusable” FOI failings cost Exeter University £15k.
Upper Tribunal delivers sharp rebuke in four-year contempt case.
What has happened?
An applicant’s four-year FOI dispute with University of Exeter has ended with the latter receiving a £15,000 fine for contempt of court.
The case began in October 2022, when the applicant sought information on community liaison work carried out by the University’s Exeter Community Panel and its Resident Liaison Group. While some material was disclosed, information relating to the membership of the two groups was withheld under sections 40 (2) (personal data) and 41 (confidential information).
The ICO upheld the refusal, so the applicant appealed to the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) and won. The FTT ruled that the “legitimate interests” in disclosure outweighed competing privacy concerns of any members in such outward-facing entities. The tribunal ordered disclosure within 42 days. The university ignored the decision.
The appellant asked the FTT to certify that the University was in contempt of court. The tribunal twice invited the University to respond to the contempt application. It ignored these requests and instead twice applied for the contempt application to be struck out, but without providing any supporting evidence.
The FTT then asked the Upper Tribunal to initiate contempt of court proceedings. Only after these had begun did the University finally release the requested information, 14 months after the FTT’s legally binding disclosure deadline. Certifying the contempt, the Upper Tribunal (UT) stopped short of finding malign intent, but delivered a scathing rebuke of the University’s conduct, citing “high-level incompetence, inexcusable mistakes and a failure to approach the order … with the seriousness that it merited”.
It was particularly troubled that the University failed to read the original ruling properly, sought no legal advice, and relied instead on “inadequate internal systems and insufficiently informed staff” before wrongly concluding that it did not need to comply.
The £15,000 fine reflected the seriousness of the breach, though could have been “considerably higher” but for the university’s apology and steps to prevent recurrence.
