18th March 2026
Row deepens over Sturgeon inquiry handling
Latest criticism follows ’embarrassing’ release of error-strewn James Hamilton files
What has happened?
The disclosures concern the 2021 James Hamilton inquiry, which cleared former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon of misconduct over her handling of disciplinary action against her predecessor, Alex Salmond
Following an FOI request, the Scottish Commissioner (SIC) ordered the release of some inquiry evidence, notably overturning the exemption for legally privileged information. Ordinarily, this is one of the hardest for requesters to challenge
The disclosure deadline passed in January, prompting SIC to refer the case to the Court of Session. Should the Court uphold the Commissioner’s appeal, the Scottish Government (SG) could be found in contempt
The SG argued release risks breaching a court order guaranteeing anonymity for Salmond’s accusers and challenged aspects of the Commissioner’s findings
Around 4,500 pages have now been released, but reports say the materials contained errors, extensive redactions and personal information, such as mobile phone numbers and addresses. This prompted some to be withdrawn, amended and republished
The SIC held a meeting with the SG’s top civil servant last week to discuss what he called its “troubling” handling of the matter. It has subsequently warned that further enforcement action may follow
