To mark October as Black History Month, we wanted to share a handful of FOI disclosures which illustrate the experiences of Britain’s Black communities.
The first – campaigner James Coombs’ fight to release obtain a Home Office commissioned report on the origins of the Windrush Scandal – West Indian immigrants who had legally entered and worked in the UK were threatened with deportation and in some cases actually deported. The Home Office had failed to keep records of legal immigrants.
The report concluded that the scandal was the result of decades of deliberately hostile immigration laws designed to deter black and brown settlers.
What happened?
• From 2021 to 2024 the Home Office resisted disclosure
• It argued that black communities’ trust in government might suffer and that disclosure would threaten the “free and frank” exchange of advice and the “safe space” that government needs to formulate policy
• The ICO accepted that the information was exempt but the First Tier Tribunal criticised the Home Office’s Orwellian approach and said the public interest was “strongly in favour of disclosure”
• It said the report made clear that it did not represent the government’s views and that “there is no new information not already in the public domain”
• The study was intended to help Home Office staff understand the history of immigration policy and of ethnic minorities in the UK. It would also, the Tribunal said, enhance public understanding of these issues.
For more detail on the decision, please read this case
James Coombs v Information Commissioner & Anor (2024) UKFTT 804 (GRC)
