INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

Campaign urges peers to back bringing ARIA under FOI

The Campaign is urging peers to support an amendment to the Advanced Research and Invention Agency Bill to bring ARIA under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) when the Bill has its report stage in the House of Lords on Tuesday 14th December 2021.

As the Bill stands ARIA will be excluded from FOIA altogether. We are encouraging peers to support Amendment 6 in the name of Lord Clement-Jones, which would make ARIA subject to FOIA.

The government says ARIA is modelled on the US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), but DARPA is covered by the US FOIA and was the subject of just 48 requests in 2019 – a volume of requests which could not conceivably be regarded as an obstacle to ARIA’s success. This is almost exactly the number of FOI requests received by individual UK research councils – whose functions are analogous to ARIA’s – before they were incorporated into UKRI. In 2017-18, the six research councils for which we have found data received an average of 48 requests each.

At the bill’s committee stage, a government minister, Lord Callanan, suggested that “comparisons between ARIA and DARPA do not hold, precisely because, as I said, DARPA adds a standard fee to the requester, which is not comparable to the situation in the UK”. However, under the US FOIA, fees are not charged to the main classes of requesters likely to be interested in DARPA, including journalists, scientific researchers and those who can show their requests are in the public interest.

Moreover, the UK FOIA provides far greater protection for public authorities against burdensome requests than the US Act. The UK legislation allows a request to be refused where the estimated cost of establishing whether information is held and locating, retrieving and extracting it would exceed either £600 or £450 depending on the authority. In 2020, this provision accounted for 42% of full refusals to disclose information by UK central government bodies. Nothing in the US FOIA provides anything like this degree of protection for government agencies.

With a budget of £800 million, ARIA will be vastly better resourced to answer FOI requests than thousands of small bodies which already comply with the Act, including parish councils, schools, GPs, police and crime commissioners, local healthwatch bodies and many others.

ARIA also cannot opt out of complying with the right of access to environmental information under the Environmental Information Regulations, as it falls within the definition of a public authority under those regulations. It will also have to comply with the right of access to personal information under data protection legislation. It will therefore need to have staff able to respond to requests under access to information legislation, so the supposed benefit to it of being exempt from FOIA is less than may be imagined.

Read our briefing for peers.

Scroll to Top