INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

New FOI disclosures puts DWP outsourcing assurances under pressure

 New FOI evidence puts DWP outsourcing assurances under pressure

 

Eligibility for PIP is assessed by contractors working for the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) whose decisions have often been criticised and associated, in some reports, with claimant harm. The department claimed historically that the process is overseen by an “independent audit team”. But a newly disclosed 2021 report just obtained via FOI shows that the staff carrying out the audits in the past were seconded from the same contractors who performed the initial assessments. Those providers were also allowed to review and challenge the findings.

PIP, formerly known as Personal Independence Payment, is a tax-free benefit that helps people with long-term health conditions or disabilities meet the additional costs of everyday life, regardless of their income or savings.

The 2021 Government Internal Audit Agency report into the quality of telephony assessments was obtained after an ICO appeal by the publication Disability News Service (DNS).

DNS said “The revelation casts huge doubt on years of audits that have shown reductions in sub-standard reports, and once again raises questions about the relationship between DWP and…outsourcing industries.

The DWP had refused to disclose the report arguing that publication could inhibit the free and frank provision of advice, the exchange of views for deliberation and the effective conduct of public affairs.

DNS complained to the Information Commission’s Office which accepted that these exemptions applied but ruled that disclosure was in the public interest. The age of the report, the need to scrutinise the evidence underpinning DWP’s public assurances, the need for oversight of contractors and the importance of knowing whether previous recommendations had been implemented all weighed in favour of transparency.

 

Scroll to Top