8th April 2026
Court of Session overrules Scottish Information Commissioner in high-profile FOI dispute
Commissioner criticised for “minimising” weight of legal professional privilege
What has happened?
The Court of Session has ruled in favour of the Scottish Government (SG) in one of a series of FOI cases concerning the James Hamilton investigation into whether former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon had breached the Scottish Ministerial Code
This case centred on a request for internal communications relating to a previous appeal, some of which had been withheld under an exemption for legal professional privilege (LPP). Ministers declined to share that material with the Scottish Information Commissioner (SIC). Authorities can withhold their legal advice on the Act, or on proceedings under the Act from the Commissioner.”
SIC argued that the public interest favoured disclosure, citing “extensive” public interest in the Sturgeon inquiry. He highlighted the SG’s description of the withheld material as “standard official level correspondence”. In his view, that characterisation indicated that little harm would result from the disclosure. He found the public interest balance favoured disclosure and ordered its release
However, the Court found that he had “wrongly minimised” the importance of LPP. The right to seek and receive legal advice in confidence is described in case law as “a fundamental human right on which the administration of justice as a whole depends.” There is always a strong public interest in protecting such information. Under FOI, it can only be overridden by particularly strong public interest arguments. The Court held that SIC was not entitled to assume that the phrase “standard official level correspondence” meant that the public interest in protecting the LPP material was diminished
The strong public interest in protecting legal advice could be overcome where there was a particularly compelling public interest in disclosure. But the court said: “We appreciate that anything relating, however indirectly, to the Hamilton investigation will be of intense interest to many members of the public, but, as has often been said, that is not the test.”
