INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

FOI and International Women’s Day

11th March 2026

FOI and International Women’s Day

Metropolitan police mishandling of violence against women highlighted by recent Times FOI battle

What has happened?
In early 2022, The Times requested internal reports from police forces on their handling of violence against women. Most complied, but the Met did not. It claimed several exemptions applied including prejudice to investigations. The ICO ordered almost total disclosure, criticising the “blanket” use of exemptions and noting that some of those cited were mutually exclusive

The Met appealed. Many months later, as the case headed to the Tribunal, it eventually released a heavily redacted version and applied to withdraw its appeal

The First Tier Tribunal (FTT) consented to withdrawal, but George Greenwood, the Times journalist, appealed against it to the Upper Tribunal (UT) and secured an important precedent that such withdrawals, if opposed, cannot take place without a hearing

The UT placed particular weight on the FTT’s disregard for the ICO’s position, stating that as the FOIA regulator, “the concern he expressed about the appeal being withdrawn needed to be addressed”

When the case returned to the FTT, near-full disclosure was ordered. Even so, the material was only released after the Times threatened the Met with contempt proceedings

The 2022 report found officers failed to record basic information in many serious sexual offence cases, including the relationship between victim and offender, missing opportunities to identify patterns of offending. Many victims had also withdrawn their cases

Scotland Yard says it has since reformed its approach, claiming more arrests and a tripling of charges

For more detail on the report, please see this article from March 2024

Scroll to Top