27th February 2026
US FOI data undermines Dept of Homeland Security’s case for immigration crackdown
77% of first time arrestees from January to mid August 2025 had no criminal conviction – and most convictions were for traffic offences, not for violence or drugs
What has happened?
Since launching the largest immigration crackdown in US history, Trump’s administration has repeatedly asserted that those targeted were “the worst of the worst”
Records obtained by the Guardian and US non-profit Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press after legal action against DHS under the US FOI Act now refute that claim
Analysis of over 138,000 documents, compiled from January to mid-August 2025 by DHS to justify deportations, indicates 77% of the immigrants targeted had no criminal convictions
The documents, known as I-213 forms, are used by DHS in court to prove someone is in the US unlawfully. They are filed when a person first encounters ICE, and DHS initiates deportation proceedings, which is usually at the point of arrest
Of the remaining 23%, nearly half were for non-violent traffic and immigration offences
Traffic offences comprised almost 30% of convictions
9% were for assault, 1% were for sexual assault and 0.5% were for homicide
According to one expert from the University of Washington Center for Human Rights: “What is being conducted is dragnet enforcement with the goal of ensnaring as many people as possible in the detention and deportation process, despite all the public claims”.
