INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

Ed Ryland and Information Commissioner & Channel 4 Television

Information Tribunal Ruling 

• A request for any correspondence “from” a specified official about a particular matter included information to that official in the same email chain, the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) has ruled.

• The requester had asked Channel 4 TV for any correspondence from its Chief Executive (CE) regarding the use of Non-Disclosure Agreement or confidentiality clauses.

• Channel 4 argued that only emails from the CE, not those to which she was responding should be disclosed. It noted that case law required that authorities follow the objective meaning of the request, read in context. The requester had specifically asked for correspondence from the CE and ‘no sensible objective reading of this would interpret it as meaning “from and to”’.

• However, the tribunal noted that the “correspondence” normally refers both to communications sent by a person and those to which they are replying. The emails sent by the CE would have included the text of those to which she was responding. The whole chain was therefore covered by the request, provided it related to the specified issue. To exclude those to which she was replying (which presumably would have been attached to her own) would artificially narrow the scope of the request. However, if the correspondence had taken place by letter, only the CE’s replies would have been covered as they would not have incorporated the text of letters to which she was responding.

• FTT decisions are not binding in other cases, but they illustrate an approach which the tribunal may follow in similar circumstances.

Scroll to Top