INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

Information Tribunal decides it cannot rely on ChatGPT logs as evidence

11th April 2025

⚖️ Information Tribunal News ⚖️

The FOI tribunal has said it cannot rely on ChatGPT’s output as evidence!

An FOI requester had asked the Department for Work and Pensions for any policy on the use of force against people filming or gathering evidence at its premises. He provided links to videos showing improper force by contractor G4S’s staff at DWP premises.

The DWP said it had provided all the information revealed by its electronic searches and by speaking to staff. The requester argued its searches were too narrow.

He fed his request into ChatGPT and asked it to list the search terms that DWP should have used. These called for wider searches than the DWP’s.

The first-tier tribunal was not persuaded. In an April 2024 decision it said that where experts gave evidence it required them to explain their expertise, sources and methodology. It expected equivalent information about ChatGPT’s credentials. But there was no evidence of its sources or methodology. Without this its suggestions could not be relied on. The DWP’s searches had been reasonable, it decided.

So even if FOI requesters find ChatGPT helpful that does not make it authoritative.

ChatGPT joinCFOI accountability transparency

Scroll to Top