INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND TRIBUNAL DECISIONS - NEXT FOI CASE LAW UPDATE 6TH JUNE 2024. RESERVE YOUR PLACE NOW!

Petition against Government refusal to release Hillsborough files

In April 2009 the BBC made a freedom of information request to the Cabinet Office asking for documents relating to the Hillsborough disaster when 96 Liverpool fans were killed in a crush at the Sheffield stadium in 1989. The BBC asked for copies of all briefings and other information provided to Margaret Thatcher in April 1989 relating to the Hillsborough disaster. The request also asked for copies of minutes and any other records of meetings attended by Margaret Thatcher during the same month at which the disaster was discussed.

After a nine-month delay, the Cabinet Office refused the request citing several exemptions, including information relating to the formulation or development of government policy and information relating to ministerial communications. The BBC subsequently requested an internal review. Following a seven-month wait the Cabinet Office upheld the previous exemptions, and added three more.

The BBC appealed this decision and took the case to the Information Commissioner. On 20th July 2011, the Information Commissioner found that the public interest favoured disclosure and ordered the information be released. The Cabinet Office is now appealing this decision saying any information must be released in line with the Hillsborough independent inquiry.

A Cabinet Office spokesman said, “The government’s view is that it is in the public interest for the process that is under way through the Hillsborough independent panel be allowed to take its course. The terms of reference for that process includes the intention to disclose information to the Hillsborough families first.” The Hillsborough Independent Panel, which was set up in 2009 by the Labour Government, began sifting through thousands of documents relating to the tragedy in February last year.

An e-petition on the Home Office website calling for the “Full disclosure of all government documents relating to 1989 Hillsborough disaster” is fast gaining momentum. Sign it here.

The Information Commissioner also criticised the Cabinet Office for “unjustified and excessive delays” in handling the BBC request.

Read the ICO decision notice here.

Scroll to Top